1 pixel image
1 pixel image

Jeroen's ongoing switch blog.

My experiences with a Powerbook 17" and 15" and comparisons with two IBM Thinkpads, a T40p and an A31.

Comparing 2 Powerbooks with 2 Thinkpads: "Powerbook vs. Thinkpad speed testing".

For the first week experiences: "First week of the switch".

1 pixel image
1 pixel image

Day 7, Friday: Bluetooth and phones.

16 April 2004


On WindowsXP I need to click on "Start", then "Connect To", "Bluetooth Connection", then press "Dial". This connects me to my home server so I can use the internet from anywhere I have mobile phone reception.

On MacOSX I have to click on the "Modem Status" icon on the menu bar, then selct "Bluetooth", select the "Modem Status" icon again and select "Connect".

This of course assumes Bluetooth phone is setup on each of thse computers, and that the "Modem Status" is visible in the menu bar on MacOSX.

To get my Siemens S55 Bluetooth phone to work with MacOSX I spent an hour trying all sorts of modem scripts without success. I was getting connections to the phone and the Windows 200 server behind me was accepting the call, but for some reason the connection was refused.

I searched online and found Ross Barkman's Home Page, which contains a large amount of phone specific modem scripts. I used the "Generic Mobile Phone Script", which is the first one I tried. I cannot believe that Apple has not included a generic mobile phone modem script.

In my comparison of the Powerbook and Thinkpad I complained about the fact the every time I opened up the IBM I had to reconnect my Bluetooth mouse. It seems that was cause by a security setting, I changed the security settings to "Medium" on my Thinkpad and now I don't need to reconnect the mouse every time!

Fast user switching is a good bit of eye candy.

Another great feature is the backup battery that keeps the computer sleeping while the main battey is changed. This is something that should be included as part of every laptop made by every manufacturer.
Not that I have a second battery, one battery charge has kept me going for 2 hours at a coffee shop in the QVB in the Sydney CBD (Bacio ( #29 on floorplan), in the center of the QVB's ground floor), with the Bluetooth on over a period of 30 minutes, and the wireless on for another 30 minutes. The battery gauge on the menu bar still said 2:13 of charge left!


One week down...

The first week has been a lot of fun. The Powerbook really is a very good computer. I do sometimes get a little confused with the change of keyboard shortcuts, and the "enter" key next to the cursor keys gets in the way too often. I find that I don't miss the Page Up/Down keys, but I do miss the Home/End keys. The substitutes will just take getting used to.

The backspace delete key does not react correctly in Adobe GoLive. I know this is not a MacOSX issue, goLive just can't keep up with the keyboard repeat rate in layout editing, it can in source editing, strange.

The Powerbook is a well designed piece of equipement, the big palmrest area, the large trackpad, the screen (oh, the screen...), the battery, the battery checker, the wireless reception, I can go on, just read the "Good" and "Bad" boxes for this week. There are problems too, no harddrive activity LED, one mouse button under the trackpad and missing keys. The "really bad" is the game support. Yes most popular games are available or will be available, but they just don't seem to be of the same quality as their Windows versions.

Over the next few weeks and months I will continue to add to the log in "my ongoing switch log.", I will do more performance tests aimed at daily usability of the computer, not high end Photoshop filters or high end 3D modelling work they mean nothing to the average computer user. I will also do some comparisons between XCode and VisuaStudio.Net as soon as I am more comfortable with XCode.

Overall this has so-far been a very positive experience, a far more seamless switch than I expected, I would suggest the switch to anyone interested.

Buy a Mac for your work, hobby, internet, word-processing, home/professional video/music and keep a cheap AMD based Windows PC with a decent video card for games that don't get ported or a quality port.

I really do not understand why Apple has the market share it has, Apple certainly deserves a much larger share of the market.

...many more to go!

 

Good

  • Overall user experience. MacOSX is nicer to use than WindowsXP.
  • Powerbook design. There are so many design touches that make the Powerbook a very useable computer.
  • Extra battery backup. Put the machine to sleep, remove the battery, re-insert the battery, wake the computer. No shutdown and startup required.
  • Battery life. Battery life on the go is much better than expected for such a large laptop.

Bad

  • No included generic mobile phone modem script. I had to suffer for some time and then found one online.
  • Adobe GoLive is slower. Adobe GoLive is slower when switching between preview, source and layout editing.

  • Apple logo on back of screen lights up, no mistaking a Powerbook in a dark room!


    most recent

    April 2004

     M 
     T 
     W 
     T 
     F 
     S 
     S 
    1 2 3 4
    5 6 7 8 9 10 11
    12 13 14 15 16 17 18
    19 20 21 22 23 24 25
    26 27 28 29 30

    email jeroen

    Other Months

    April 2006
    September 2004
    August 2004
    July 2004
    June 2004
    May 2004
    April 2004